
My beef is with the terms “uninformed” and “failure to understand” (I have even seen “under-informed” used). They are frequently touted to make a candidate seem dangerously uneducated on a position or issue concerning the voting public. The underlying problem I see, however, is what I’ll call the “I’m right, you’re wrong” approach to politics. Saying that someone is uninformed is really saying, “if you knew all the facts, you would have no choice but to see things the way I do.”
That’s fine rhetoric if you are talking about a bridge that is washed out down the road—there is such a thing as absolute truth—but it has no value in issues like the war in Iraq, the economy, or the energy situation. I imagine the candidates are ten times more “informed” than the average citizen will ever be. But each will look at those issues and see a different problem, a different solution.
I’m sensitive to this because it is an all-too-common tactic in personal interactions, not just politics. And it used to be part of my own arsenal in my younger days. I’m right, you’re wrong. End of discussion. In this particular season, party lines form. We’re right. You’re all wrong. End of discussion.
It’s the last sentence there that scares me the most.
“As I look at the world, nothing has really changed. The evidence is the same. But I have changed.” –an atheist scientist who becomes a Christian in Creature Tech by Doug TenNapel
4 comments:
Hi Daniel! Finally my chance to thank you for the comments you've left on my blog.
I totally agree with this post--end of story! :)
Interested in doing a guest post on my blog? ;) It would probably be pretty hard to top your dad's carrot post.
Well said.
wades--I enjoy your blog--we hope to see the ranch when we are down there.
I don't think I could top Dad's carrot post. The best I could do would be a blog on "how to place the robber on someone's tile and still get good trades from them later in the game."
tj and mark--thanks. I feel better after venting.
daniel,
how bout we play a little settlers when you're in town? i get red guys! :)
i think i'd be pretty interested in that post--handy knowledge!
i'd love to meet juliet. :)
Post a Comment